On the contrary, anything unscientific is great. I am a musician myself and I find proof based scientific discussions very claustrophobic at times.
All I am trying to say is, in this case, the article is a bunch of opinion from a Jazz musician about fellow Jazz musicians and bands. How does this fit in with other HN threads?
I would say that something like Frank Zappa on censorship [1] [2] is much more suited to HN discussion than this link.
" I am a musician myself and I find proof based scientific discussions very claustrophobic at times."
How do you rate the musicians you play with?
I have to make judgements about students and (at this time of year) prospective students in terms of which course and which level to allocate them to.
I imagine that the founders of a startup who are responding to a sudden increase in use/market have to make judgements about their colleagues when scaling up the responsibilties.
The way Davis is making judgements about his peers and the particular recordings shows something about his approach.
All I am trying to say is, in this case, the article is a bunch of opinion from a Jazz musician about fellow Jazz musicians and bands. How does this fit in with other HN threads?
I would say that something like Frank Zappa on censorship [1] [2] is much more suited to HN discussion than this link.
[1] http://www.joesapt.net/superlink/shrg99-529/p51.html#fztesti...
[2] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8ISil7IHzxc