Hey now Accusey Adam (or is it Conjecturey Constance?), put down the pitchfork. There's no need to accuse people of sockpuppeting/gaming just because you don't like their project. It's hurtful to hear people call you a cheater when you just want to get feedback on your project.
Tamal has a pretty neat looking service (yes, one that's been done before, but still pretty neat). I've seen SPLASH PAGES with zero functionality get more votes on HN; why shouldn't Tamal get his 15 minutes?