Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> local electromagnetic event then I'd prefer to have a backup that can handle that.

First of all, the magnetic gauss needed to flip bits on LTO media is huge. It's not a practical concern unless you're choosing an incredibly inappropriate storage location.

Second, why wouldn't you store your tapes in a case or a vault that is magnetically shielded?

You probably store your discs in cases, instead of insisting they be naturally durable against rough handling and abrasion.



> First of all, the magnetic gauss needed to flip bits on LTO media is huge. It's not a practical concern unless you're choosing an incredibly inappropriate storage location.

You're right, it does seem huge: https://superuser.com/a/568367/111650

(Some of the links from this answer are quite interesting.)

The issue is that I don't know (and I suspect it's difficult to know or even classified) whether an EMP attack (the main scenario I'm worried about, which can be quite powerful) would be sufficient to cause damage. I don't believe there is a consensus on this though I'd be glad to be proved wrong here.

> why wouldn't you store your tapes in a case or a vault that is magnetically shielded?

I would; as I said I put some magnetic hard drives in Faraday cages. However, I'm not confident that the Faraday cage would be sufficient. A lot of the discussion online about constructing Faraday cages to protect electronics is speculation. I haven't seen any clear data showing that during an EMP attack magnetic data is protected inside of a Faraday cage, or protected without one.


> I'm not confident that the Faraday cage would be sufficient.

Faraday cages are not intended for that purpose.

Magnetic shielding is a well understood concept. What you need is some thickness of ferrous metals.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_shielding#Magn...

https://web.archive.org/web/20070327130322/https://advancema...

https://interferencetechnology.com/magnetic-shielding-basics...

It's easy to test the efficacy of magnetic shielding yourself if you have a large, powerful magnet and a CRT monitor handy.


Noted, thank you much.


The EMP from a nuclear weapon is mostly radio frequency and would be picked up by antennas, power lines and such. (I know an ex-military ham who always unplugs his HF/shortwave radio from the antenna and power when he's not using it because that's what they taught him to do back in the day.)

I don't see that kind of EMP erasing magnetic media.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: