Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Please provide clarification: is something "relative" if people disagree on it? If there are two different interpretations of a single data set, for example, does it mean that the reality of what that data means is "relative" or just that one or both interpretation don't have enough information (or appropriate understanding of it)?

Basically, I want to know what "relativism" actually means to you since your quote seems to imply that anything you think about is "relative". Thank you, I'm excited to hear your response.



Moral relativism is the opposite of moral absolutism.

Moral absolutism is the belief that certain actions are intrinsically moral or immoral.

For example, cannibalism. Say there is some tribe that eats their dead. A moral absolutist would say that "cannibalism is immoral", and therefore conclude that the tribe is immoral[1].

Whereas a moral relativist would say that, if you had grown up in a tribe of cannibals, then eating people would be a perfectly normal thing to do, it would be moral from the tribe's reference frame, and immoral from our reference frame.

Yes, different moral systems can be compared along certain objective dimensions. Objectively, cannibalism causes certain diseases such as kuru.

However, choosing which dimensions to optimise for is itself a subjective process. Objectively, cannibalism prevents food waste :)

Relativism is precisely what allows for meaningful disagreements to occur. Otherwise a disagreement would simply degenerate into a loud exchange of axioms (this often happens).

My problem with moral absolutism is that it requires a healthy dose of chronocentrism to buy into it without reference to some codified set of morals such as a religion. What is considered moral or immoral has changed dramatically in the last century alone. At some point in the future, our morality will be as unrecognisable to future generations as Ancient Greek morality is to us.

[1] Historically, this sort of moral absolutism was the impetus for certain missionary activity. No not that kind.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: