Privacy is not something Apple, or any company, gives us. But it’s something they extract from us; by tracking us and harvesting data. If Apple were serious, as opposed to positioning themselves as less extractive than GFAM and others, they would not be taking this road. Yes, they say it’s on iCloud for now, but the signs are that it will be done client side in future. Whether you believe that will happen or not the risks are too high; so it’s prudent to assume the worst.
This is this a first step to "Detective in your Pocket", cloaked intentionally, or not, by a well-meaning objective. An objective we can all support. If you wanted to put in a thin wedge on distributed surveillance, where better to start? As pointed out CSAM filtering/scanning is already done so that’s not the issue here. There’s a big debate to be had, and being had, on the upsides/downsides and benefits/dangers of AI and false positives. That’s a huge issue in itself; but that’s not the biggest concern with this move. If Apple pushes on with this it’s a clear signal that they wish to march us all to a new world order with Distributed Surveillance, as a Service. A march in step with the drumbeat of your increasingly authoritarian (or if you are lucky or more generous, safety conscious) government.
I have signed the letter to express my very strong personal concerns but also as a CEO of a company that takes CSAM seriously and seeks to provide solutions, in search, without surveillance.
This is this a first step to "Detective in your Pocket", cloaked intentionally, or not, by a well-meaning objective. An objective we can all support. If you wanted to put in a thin wedge on distributed surveillance, where better to start? As pointed out CSAM filtering/scanning is already done so that’s not the issue here. There’s a big debate to be had, and being had, on the upsides/downsides and benefits/dangers of AI and false positives. That’s a huge issue in itself; but that’s not the biggest concern with this move. If Apple pushes on with this it’s a clear signal that they wish to march us all to a new world order with Distributed Surveillance, as a Service. A march in step with the drumbeat of your increasingly authoritarian (or if you are lucky or more generous, safety conscious) government.
I have signed the letter to express my very strong personal concerns but also as a CEO of a company that takes CSAM seriously and seeks to provide solutions, in search, without surveillance.