Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I’m mostly a Mac user, but when setting up a friend’s Windows 10 PC, I used the Windows Store to download whatever apps I could that were available there, and only installed from the web for apps that didn’t have Windows Store versions.

My thinking is:

1. apps on the Windows Store have some level of sandboxing forced upon them, so I can rest assured that the Windows Store releases of these apps won’t make a mess of their computer, even after major-version updates. (Remember uTorrent?)

2. Windows Store apps get automatically updated in the background without ever running them—like apps installed via the OS package manager on Linux. Give some people any chance to cancel/delay an update, and they’ll do it, indefinitely. Better for most regular users [who aren’t relying on any reflexive professional workflows] to have their apps just “be” the newest version, at all times.



The sandboxing part isn't quite true anymore. You can use Desktop Bridge to package win32 apps for the store. These apps are not sandboxed in the way that UWP apps are though they are still kinda-sorta sandboxed (they can access any file the user can, but the appdata folder and registry edits are sandboxed).

There is also some sort of vaguely-stated plan to allow totally unsandboxed win32 apps in the store at some point in the future but seems to specifically only apply to games.

https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/msix/desktop/deskto...


Aren't games the easiest apps to sandbox? They do everything custom and it's not like they even need an open file dialog.


Except for the copy protection, anti cheat system and the low level access that is required for performance.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: