Hacker Timesnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There's always been something fishy about 37signals that I can't put my finger on. I respect what they've done but know that I definitely don't want to run a company like they do. Firstly, they charge for everything they possible can. This is not necessarily bad in and of itself but at some point they stop feeling like a product company. First and foremost they're a brand company. I can't help but think they'll sacrifice quality in any other area if it helps their brand out. That's probably not entirely fair, but it's the picture they've painted.

I just want to build cool stuff. I know brand is important but it seems silly to me to try and make a career out of blathering about how awesomely I build cool stuff and how much I just get it where so many others don't.



We tried basecamp for awhile but then grew out of it. Then we tried Highrise when it came out - found it pretty much useless. Lots of people heeded their call for simplicity and the fight against feature creep and that's a good thing. But when their own products begin to get lapped by competitors and the new stuff they are releasing isn't very useful, then there are problems. That said, I don't blame them necessarily for charging people for all this stuff; at $100/person, they probably actually wouldn't make very much money - they need to rent space, get some food, pay for A/V, etc. Going to a developer conference is one thing, but I'm not sure it would be worth a day to hear how someone is using a glorified web form as a collaboration tool.


My impression of them has always been that they are the Apple of webapps. They have style, grace, and a cult following. They also have a reality distortion field, will nickel and dime their customers, and if you don't get it then it's your fault you suck.


That's quite an interesting view. To be honest I loved 37Signals approach to web apps and how they initially shunned outside funding to build their business. Granted that they started out as a consulting company? then morphed into a product company(which is an ideal route if you don't take oustide funding) But these days I'm finding it hard to use Basecamp(although they claim they produce easy to use software) I hope that they don't lose their initial focus. Their business model is sound so is their choice of niche market. Hope they don't stray away from that successful formula.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: